“Automated Finance, Human Consequences: Plazo Urges Caution on AI in the Markets”
“Automated Finance, Human Consequences: Plazo Urges Caution on AI in the Markets”
Blog Article
Inside the Asian Institute of Management, Joseph Plazo—founder of the algorithmic trading firm Plazo Sullivan Roche—broke the rhythm of praise for AI with a moment of reckoning.
From Manila, where financial optimism runs high — He didn’t celebrate victory margins or machine performance.
“The machine may be faster. But are we still the ones deciding what matters?”
???? **Joseph Plazo: A Technologist Sounding the Alarm**
He’s not critiquing technology from a safe distance. His firm’s AI systems have posted a 99% win rate across key timeframes and are in use by institutional clients across Europe and Asia.
Yet even with these results, he insists—performance isn’t the only metric.
“AI can optimise a mistake to perfection if no one stops it.”
He shared a case from the early days of the pandemic. One of his firm’s bots flagged a short on gold just before the U.S. Federal Reserve issued an emergency policy shift.
“We overrode it. It was a machine doing math, not reading history.”
???? **Machines Act Fast. But Leadership Sometimes Waits.**
AI’s appeal lies in its instant execution. But at what cost?
“We must remember that a moment of hesitation can more info protect reputations—and futures.”
Plazo introduced a framework he calls **“Conviction Calculus”**—three questions that must be asked before executing an AI recommendation:
- Who takes responsibility if the code is flawless—but the outcome disastrous?
- Is there non-digital confirmation? What do experience, memory, and culture say?
- Does leadership end when the model takes over?
???? **Asia’s Race Toward AI Could Be Missing Its Compass**
Across Asia, nations are investing heavily in fintech and AI-driven innovation. From Singapore to South Korea, the push toward automation is framed as economic strategy.
But Plazo’s question cuts deeper: “Are we building intelligence without wisdom?”
He cited the 2024 collapse of two Hong Kong hedge funds.
“No one made a mistake. But no one questioned the machine either.”
???? **A New Path: Machines That Listen as Well as Compute**
Plazo is not anti-AI. He’s pro-responsibility.
His firm is developing what he calls **“narrative-integrated AI”**—models that factor in geopolitics, tone, and social context alongside market data.
“We don’t need more speed. We need better questions.”
Regional investors are exploring what responsible algorithmic finance might look like.
One investor called Plazo’s talk:
“A reminder that the tools we build still need human hands at the wheel.”
???? **The Collapse That Could Begin in Silence**
Plazo ended with a thought that may echo across boardrooms:
“The next crash won’t come from fear,” he said. “It’ll come from logic—executed too quickly, by systems no one dared to question.”
No dramatic flourish. Just clarity.
Because when machines take over the trades, someone must still own the consequences.